I just read Bob Rae’s wide-ranging edited book Reclaiming Canadian Sovereignty. It discusses many areas of sovereignty: trade, economics, national defence, the environment, the north, and culture. I will focus on culture because I believe that widespread knowledge of our history and a strong national identity serve as the best bulwarks for resisting the mixture of intimidation and allure in the meme “fifty-first state.”
Culture is an area my coauthor Beth Herst and I have thought deeply about in writing the chapter of our book Public Representations titled “’As Canadian as Possible, Under the Circumstances’: Public Sphere Screen Stories and Small Markets.” In it, we deal with the challenges of producing screen stories about politics in our small English-language market, which is dominated by stories from the US and the UK.
What is to be Done?
Two chapters of Rae’s book – by Margaret Atwood and Richard Stursberg – focus on cultural sovereignty. Atwood celebrates the flourishing of Canadian writing since she began her iconic career six decades ago. Government support for writing, like other art forms, has increased dramatically since then. Now we are facing the problem that the demand for funding is increasing while the supply is holding steady or diminishing, which she calls “proliferation and shrinkage.” She recognizes that today’s new environment demands new policy approaches if Canadian writing is to continue to thrive.
Richard Stursberg, a former CEO of Telefilm Canada and head of English services at the CBC, makes a comprehensive argument that expands on Atwood’s personal experience. He discusses the flowering of Canada music, novels, and non-fiction from the Sixties to the Eighties, supported by the cultural nationalism of the Pearson and (Pierre) Trudeau Governments. Since the signing of NAFTA in 1994, there have been numerous developments that have undercut Canadian cultural sovereignty, including the sale of Canadian publishers to larger US houses, budget cuts to cultural programs by the Chretien Government, and the Harper Government’s budget cuts to the CBC. He concludes that if Canadians, especially the young, don’t know their country and their history, they will have less pride in it and willingness to sacrifice for it.
As part of his argument, Stursberg notes with apparent regret that it was over 20 years ago that the CBC commissioned mini-series on the lives of Pierre Trudeau, Rene Levesque, Tommy Douglas, and about the October Crisis. Stursberg is being disingenuous because he was the head of English services at the CBC from 2004 to 2010, as we discuss in Public Representations (pp. 264-65, 274-75). Under his watch, the mini-series about Rene Levesque and the October Crisis were scheduled at times they would not be noticed. Stursberg’s preferred alternative to political docudrama was political comic opera, but his two commissions (one on Brian Mulroney, the other on Jean Chretien) were unsuccessful and led to his being fired in 2010. This backstory should have warranted at least a personal disclosure. Stursberg might have made his overall argument stronger if he admitted to changing his mind.
What is now Being Done?
The Carney Government’s 2026 budget seems to have recognized the argument for the importance of cultural sovereignty and is allocating $4 billion in new funding over 5 years. This package of programs includes $600 million to the audio- and audio-visual sectors to replace funding from taxing digital streaming services, to which the Trump administration vigorously objected.
The National Film Board was not included in the package, but earlier in the year it received an additional $26 million over 3 years, which will more than offset planned cuts of $ 8 million over that period. However, its base funding remains at approximately $70 million, less than half of what it received in the early Nineties.
In Public Representations, we observe that the NFB has played a key role in supporting documentaries about Canadian politics. Because documentary is much less expensive than docudrama, we conclude that if there is to be a future for Canadian screen stories about politics, it will likely be in documentary. We regret that the Carney Government is not funding the NFB more generously.
The budget also includes $30 million over 4 years to start a national digital collection of Canadian books. I would like that taken a step further to create a national digital collection of significant Canadian film. To its credit, the NFB has made its entire library of films available online and this library gets considerable traffic, both from Canadians and non-Canadians. In contrast, the CBC has not made available on Gem, its streaming service, the docudramas about Pierre Trudeau, Rene Levesque, Tommy Douglas, and the October Crisis. Nor has it made available Quentin Durgens, MP, its path-breaking dramatic series in the Sixties about Canadian politics. Its episodes are available on tape in the archives in the basement of its broadcast centre in Toronto. If preserving books is important to cultural sovereignty, why not film?

Leave a Reply